THE fast and dramatic fall in Australia’s house values is not a crash but the result of a perfect storm of events, according to Cotality’s research director Tim Lawless.
Cotality’s national Home Value Index dipped 1.2 per cent in October, taking the downturn into a seventh consecutive month. T
The speed of decline was tracking faster than any previous downturn over the past 40 years.
The number of home sales over the past three months has also fallen 23 per cent lower than a year ago.
§ Rapid falls but not a housing crash
“Even though we are seeing housing values falling quite rapidly and substantially, I wouldn't really describe this as a crash,” Lawless told Australian Conveyancer’s What’s Next? forum in Sydney on Tuesday.
“We're not expecting the market to be down, say, 20 per cent or 30 per cent, or anything like that.
"But absolutely there are some markets where values were rising clearly, unsustainably quickly. Perth was the best example. Maybe Adelaide as well, and Brisbane also.”
§ Melbourne affordability offers buying opportunities
While values in those markets virtually doubled in six years, the story has been different in Melbourne, with housing values down around eight per cent on five years ago.
“(Melbourne) has come into this downturn from an already very weak footing,” Lawless said.
But he admitted some blue chip markets such as the inner east, bayside and Mornington Peninsula had crashed, with values plunging up to 30 per cent.
However, he predicted Melbourne was most likely to outperform over the coming two to three years, given its affordability.
“We haven't seen the gap between Melbourne and Sydney housing prices this wide since at least 1980. It's nearly a 60 per cent difference in the median value, so I'd look towards Melbourne as being a bit of an outlier,” he said.
“There's some really good buying opportunities in some of these markets that have been very weak for a long time.
"But clearly, the unsustainability and price growth in those mid-sized capitals was a real thing.”
§ Adelaide described as the riskiest market
Lawless described Adelaide as the “riskiest” market, which when adjusted for local incomes, was more expensive than Sydney.
“It's got one of the lowest yields, it’s got negative interstate migration now and very high levels of property, which keeps piling on the market as well. It does look like Queensland and WA to some extent have stronger fundamentals.”
§ A perfect storm of inflation, conflict and tax reform
Lawless said the market’s weaker performance began with a rise of inflation that led to a rise in interest rates.
The outbreak of the Middle East conflict then saw oil prices rocket and confidence plummet.
Then, in the May Budget, the government reformed negative gearing and capital gains tax arrangements in a bid to help more Aussies into the housing market.
However, this had an "amplification effect which has just seen every sector of the market fall out”.
While investors were most affected, first home buyers and non-first home buyers have also become less active in the property market.
“In many ways, this is a perfect storm,” Lawless said.
While investors pulled back around three per cent in the last quarter, renters have hit a ceiling on how much they can pay.
As a result, they are forming larger or multigenerational households and returning to mum and dad, Lawless said.
He expected to see signs of rates coming down in the second half of 2027.
Real Estate Institute of NSW president Thomas McGlynn said, while prices are down, the biggest challenge is the reduced sales volumes, which prevents vendors from having comparable examples.
“Even looking back, recent sales that happened three months ago are not accurate for where the property’s true value properly sits today,” McGlynn said.
“You've got buyers, sellers and real estate agents all trying to find their feet at exactly the same time. That's why we're seeing days on market blow out.”
McGlynn said conditions were already softening before the Budget tax reforms.
“That just sped up everything,” he said.
“I don't think people have fallen out of love with property. They're falling out of love with the complex scenarios attached to buying property.
“The hardest thing at the moment is people getting their heads around the different prices in the market now.
“There's buyers that want to buy but there's a gap between buyer and seller expectations.”
While auction volumes were down as agents shifted towards private sales in the current climate, auctions still performed better based on a 45-day window, he said.
While prices may be more subdued, interest rate hikes made home buying more expensive.
“The challenge is that prices have come back in many markets by a considerable amount, but people's borrowing power has also changed.”
Blue chip markets especially offered “amazing” buying opportunities right now, but buyers “still need to be courageous”.
“They're still anxious: is the market going to fall even further?”
Frequently asked questions
Which blue chip Melbourne markets does Tim Lawless say had crashed?
What do lower sales volumes mean for vendors?
When does Lawless expect signs of interest rates falling?
In this story
:quality(90))

:quality(82))
:quality(80))
:quality(80))
:quality(80))